Service
Talk to our team to start saving 800.260.5355
Blog
A young father holds his child while talking to a loan representative on the phone, with bills and an open laptop on the table in front of him.

What Is a Car Loan Settlement?

04
/
23
/
2025

Sometimes a car loan can be a bigger burden than you expected. The interest rate is too high, the payments are too expensive, and you don’t have enough money to pay all of your bills and your car loan, too.

When your car payments are too steep, settling the debt could be one way out. A car loan settlement is an agreement between you and your auto lender that states they’ll settle your loan for less than the total amount owed. While it may help you escape a costly car loan, settling a debt can also harm your credit. This article will help you learn tips for negotiating a settlement and what it means for your finances.

How does a car loan settlement work?

When settling a car loan, you negotiate with your lender to find a payment amount they find acceptable for discharging the debt. For example, imagine you took out a loan for $25,000 two years ago, and you still owe $19,000. You’re three months behind on your payments. You might ask the lender if they’d accept a settlement of $16,000 if you paid it all in one lump sum within the next 30 days. The lender might agree to that settlement offer, or they might decline it, or they may counter and say “$18,000” instead.

Car loan settlements are often used when someone is struggling to make their payments. It’s a way to give the lender at least some of what you owe, even if it’s not the full amount. It can also allow you to keep your car and avoid repossession.

You’ll still be on the hook to pay whatever lump sum you negotiate. That money might come from a few places — savings, a personal loan, borrowing from family, or selling another asset. Some borrowers even use debt settlement companies, though those often charge fees.

How to negotiate a car loan payoff settlement

Before you jump straight to negotiating with your lender about your debt, make sure you’re prepared. Follow the steps below to learn how to negotiate a car payoff settlement for the best outcome.

Know what you owe

First, make sure you understand what remains on your car loan – including any late fees or penalties. Check your most recent statement, view your online account dashboard or call your lender to find out your payment amount. You’ll also need to determine how much you can afford to pay toward a settlement.

Request a hardship plan

Contact your lender to let them know you’re struggling financially. Ideally, you’ll communicate that as soon as you find yourself having a difficult time making your payments. Explain your situation, such as if you’ve had a recent job loss or unexpected medical bills. Ask whether they can work with you on a hardship plan and make it clear that you want to find a solution to your problem that also works for the lender.

 

Offer a lump sum

Once you know how much you can afford to pay, propose a settlement offer. This would be one lump sum amount that you can afford, and the lender might accept instead of repossessing your car. If you can offer a lump sum to be paid right away, it might be more appealing to the lender than waiting around for small amounts to trickle in from you.

Pros and cons of settling a car loan

Settling a car loan can be a way to escape expensive debt, but it’s not without its downsides, some of which can have serious consequences for your financial situation. Think carefully about the pros and cons of settling your car debt before you move forward with this option.

Benefits of car loan settlements

  • Save money: If you can settle for less than you originally owed, that’s money you don’t have to pay toward the loan.
  • Avoid repossession: Settling a car loan can help you avoid repossession, meaning you’ll be able to keep your car to get to work and other places.
  • Get free from your loan: It may be a relief to get out from under this loan, especially if the debt has been weighing on you.

Drawbacks of car loan settlements

  • Your credit takes a hit: Settling a car loan will harm your credit score. While you can live with a low credit score, it will make it more difficult (or at least more expensive) if you need credit in the future, whether for a student loan, personal loan, mortgage or credit card.
  • The process may take a while: Sometimes, debt settlement can take several months as you negotiate your way through. Be prepared for an extended process, which may add to the headache of dealing with this debt.
  • You may owe taxes on the forgiven amount: The IRS considers forgiven debt to be a form of income, so you may owe taxes on that amount in the year you settle.

Of course, this also assumes you have the cash to settle the loan. Coming up with enough money to send your lender to settle the debt might be extra challenging if you’re already struggling financially.

Alternatives to a car loan settlement

If a car loan settlement isn’t the right path forward for you, there are other options. 

Refinancing car loans is a common strategy to lower your car payment. Refinancing involves taking out a new loan, which pays off and replaces your old car loan. Many lenders offer refinance auto loans with affordable rates, and refinancing won’t harm your credit the way a car loan settlement can.

Loan modification is another strategy to ease the burden of expensive auto loan debt. You keep the same loan, but you negotiate with your lender to change the terms and make it more affordable.

Voluntary repossession is a third method, but it should really be your last resort. When you voluntarily surrender or give up your car, it’s still considered a default and can hurt your credit. Plus, the lender often will put your car up for sale at auction or to a wholesale market. Whatever they get they’ll apply toward your loan. If there’s a balance remaining after that, you’ll still need to pay it.

FAQs

The following are some of the most frequently asked questions about car loan settlements.

Will loan settlement affect my credit score?

Yes, a car loan settlement will negatively affect your credit score. That’s because you’re not fulfilling your side of your loan agreement. A settlement can stay on your credit report for seven years. However, if the car loan is truly a financial burden, it might be worth it to you to take the hit to your credit.

Is there any debt relief for car loans?

A car loan settlement is essentially a form of debt relief specifically for auto debt. By settling your car loan, you and the lender agree to a plan that will relieve you of the debt. You’ll still owe the lender, but the amount may be less than you would owe otherwise.

Can you negotiate a car loan payoff settlement?

Yes, you can and should negotiate with the lender to find a solution that works for both of you. That might mean negotiating a settlement amount that’s smaller than your remaining balance, but it can also involve arranging a payment plan that works for your budget and the lender’s bottom line.

How long does the car loan settlement process take?

It can take weeks or months to submit your proposed offer and negotiate a settlement with your auto loan lender. If you’re struggling to make your loan payments, make sure you contact your lender right away. Waiting can add penalties, fees and interest to the amount you owe.

Back to All Articles

Helpful Articles

A young father holds his child while talking to a loan representative on the phone, with bills and an open laptop on the table in front of him.
04
/
23
/
2025
What Is a Car Loan Settlement?

Explore how a car loan settlement can impact your finances and credit rating, providing insights into this crucial decision for borrowers.

A young man sits in the driver’s seat of a new car with a young woman in the passenger seat beside him
04
/
17
/
2025
How to Get Out of a Car Lease Early

Learn effective strategies on how to break a car lease early and avoid unnecessary costs during the process. Get out of your lease early.

Automotive mechanic wearing gloves pulls a dipstick from a car engine
04
/
08
/
2025
How Much Does an Extended Warranty Cost?

Explore the common extended car warranty cost, including factors affecting pricing and different warranty levels for vehicle protection.